Biochar is charcoal made for use in soil. The research suggests it can help in some soils, particularly strongly acidic, sandy or degraded ones, but results vary a lot between soils, crops and biochar types. It is not a guaranteed upgrade for a healthy garden bed.
If you do try it, mix it with compost or another nutrient source first rather than digging it in raw.
What is biochar, exactly?
Biochar is made by heating plant material (wood, crop residue, green waste) with very little oxygen, a process called pyrolysis. What is left is a porous, carbon-rich solid that breaks down very slowly in soil.
That is different from the ash in a fire pit or a lump of barbecue charcoal. Biochar varies with its feedstock and the temperature it was made at, and those differences change how it behaves in the soil. The same word covers products that act quite differently.
Does biochar actually improve soil?
Sometimes. The pattern across the published research is more consistent than the marketing, and also more modest.
- Acidic soils respond best. A 2025 meta-analysis of 286 articles, summarised by the University of Western Australia’s repository, found biochar raised soil pH by about 7% and yields by about 21% on average in acidic soils. The biggest gains were in strongly acidic soils (below pH 4.5) with low fertility, and in the tropics.
- Very acidic soils again. A review including Queensland DAF researchers, Bai and colleagues (2022), reported the largest yield gains in soils at pH 5 or below. They also found the biochar’s production temperature mattered.
- Field results can be mixed. Six field trials in tropical north Queensland, across bananas, sugarcane, corn, peanut and pawpaw, reported significant variation in crop yield and growth. The abstract does not declare a clear winner.
Averages hide a wide spread. Published studies also tend to be commercial farm or research-plot scale, and a pH 4.5 paddock is not a typical backyard bed. The sandy-soil benefit is commonly linked to better water and nutrient holding, but I could not confirm that against a source I opened, so treat it as plausible rather than established.
Which soils are most likely to benefit?
| Soil situation | Likelihood of a noticeable benefit |
|---|---|
| Strongly acidic soil (pH below about 5) | Best-supported by the research |
| Sandy, low-organic-matter soil | Plausible; evidence less direct |
| Already near neutral, well-composted garden soil | Little reason to expect much |
| Alkaline soil | Not a target; some biochars raise pH |
Test your pH and look at your soil before buying anything. The main watering and soil guide covers how to read what your soil is doing, and in many beds regular compost and mulch do the same job more cheaply.
Why can raw biochar make plants worse at first?
Fresh biochar is porous and can hold onto nutrients, especially nitrogen, so they are less available to plants for a while. A conference abstract on biochar and nitrate notes that biochar is often pre-loaded with nutrients before use to prevent early suppression of plant growth.
The effect depends on the biochar and the soil, so not every garden sees it. But it is the main reason experienced users avoid tipping raw biochar straight into a vegetable bed.
How do you charge biochar before using it?
Charging means loading the biochar with nutrients and microbes before it goes in the ground. The simplest home method is to use compost, which also matches the research direction above.
- Break the biochar into small pieces, wearing a dust mask, and wet it so it does not blow around.
- Mix it into finished compost, or add it to a compost heap as it builds. The Goldschmidt abstract suggests co-composting may be a better loading method, since co-composted biochar released nitrate slowly.
- Leave the mix to sit for a few weeks, keeping it damp.
- Blend it into the soil or potting mix at the rate on the product label or advised by the research for your biochar.
- Water in well and mulch as usual.
Different biochars behave differently, so follow the label for your product. Avoid adding more than that, as piling on extra has not been shown to help.
Is biochar worth the money for a home garden?
For most home gardens, it is a modest optional extra. The honest summary from the research above is that benefits are real in specific conditions and uncertain in others, and the Queensland field trials found yield responses that varied by crop.
Ask three questions before buying:
- Is my soil acidic, sandy or degraded? If it is dark, crumbly and growing well, the case is weak.
- Have I already fixed the basics? Compost, mulch and correct watering usually come first. Rainwater use is covered in the rainwater versus tap water article.
- Can I try it on one bed? Treat half a bed and compare. That is better evidence for your soil than any average.
Biochar prices vary widely by supplier and bag size, so compare cost per litre and ask what feedstock it was made from.
Should you make biochar yourself?
Making it at home usually means burning material in a backyard drum or pit. Check your local fire and council rules before burning any garden waste, as what is allowed varies by council, state and season. Smoke can also affect neighbours.
If burning is not permitted or practical, buy finished biochar or take your green waste to a council collection.
Does climate change the answer?
The research gives the tropics the strongest reported gains, which is partly because many tropical and subtropical soils are old, acidic and low in nutrients. That is relevant to parts of coastal and northern Queensland, but local soil varies street by street, even there.
In temperate gardens, in Tasmania and on cool highlands, the studies I opened do not give direct guidance, so the sensible approach is the same everywhere: test pH, trial one bed, and judge by your own results over a full growing season rather than a single crop.
Common mistakes
- Digging raw biochar in and expecting an instant boost.
- Using it as a replacement for compost rather than alongside it.
- Applying it to soil that is already healthy, then crediting it with results that regular care would have delivered.
- Assuming every product is the same, when feedstock and production temperature differ.
- Treating biochar as a fertiliser. It is a carrier and conditioner, so plants still need feeding, for example with a seaweed and fish tonic routine or compost.
The short version
Established: biochar can raise pH and yield in strongly acidic soils, and research reviews report large variation between studies. Uncertain: how much it helps in typical home garden soils and which products work best. Climate-dependent: the tropics show some of the largest reported gains, while temperate and cool gardens have less direct evidence.
If you try it, charge it with compost first, use it at the product label rate, and compare against an untreated patch.





No comment yet, add your voice below!